Book Review of Mansoor Ladha’s Memoirs of a Muhindi: Fleeing East Africa for the West

By NIZAR MOTANI

________________________________________________________
Memoirs of a Muhindi: Fleeing East Africa for the West
By Mansoor Ladha,
252 pp. University of Regina Press,
CDN$ 23.15 (at Amazon), Kindle Edition CDN$ 11.19
________________________________________________________

Memoirs of a Muhindi by Mansoor Ladha

Memoirs of a Muhindi by Mansoor Ladha

Since the word Diaspora is encountered in many written accounts and conversations, the author has, thankfully, shed light on it.

“In Greek, the word diaspora means “to scatter,” but today we use the term to describe a community of people who live outside their country of origin or ancestry but maintain connections with it. A diaspora includes both emigrants and their descendants. While some people lose their attachment to their ancestral homeland, others maintain a strong connection to a place their ancestors may have left generations ago.”

As most of the Africa-born Asians reside in the West and their numbers are dwindling through natural causes, Ladha has taken upon himself to relate his own personal experiences and historical events about life in colonial and independent East Africa. And he has done a splendid job using his multiple journalistic skills.

I wish I had read and discussed his memoir with my family and friends much earlier.

The first generation in the West will see themselves in Ladha’s story; the diasporic generations born outside East Africa will learn about their parents’ unsustainable situation in East Africa and their dispossession, displacement and resettlement in North America and Western Europe.

Surprisingly, Ladha does not explain – for the benefit of the Western-born generations and other potential readers – “who is a muhindi?” until page 16! Muhindi is a Swahili word to describe a person of Asian descent. Simply put, it refers to a brown-skinned person.

To this reviewer, a Uganda-born third generation muhindi with a doctorate in African history, expelled by the notorious Idi Amin in 1972, Ladha’s memoir is replete with unusual personal experiences and less-known historical events.

An excellent discussion of the three-tier colonial, racially-structured system, which controlled, segregated and shaped race-relations, attitudes, behavior and opportunities in British East Africa, sets the stage for his story of navigating it hurdles. Under this racially segregated system, during and after the colonial period, Ladha takes the readers to places where most muhindis could not or would not go.

He is a self-proclaimed man with pride and principles. So when things turn out according to his expectations, he is happy; when they don’t, he is furious. Through this rather unorthodox muhindi, we get to visit: the palace of the Sultan of Zanzibar for an audience, while still in primary school; the British-controlled newspaper, The Standard, where he was the only Asian reporter and a copy editor; President Nyerere’s State House as the only Asian in the University of Dar-es-Salaam’s student executive committee, which went to protest the terms of the National Service (which he calls national servitude), resulting in their arrest, expulsion from the university, and deportation to their hometowns; the Nation House in Nairobi, Kenya, where he was given an expatriate   white person’s most privileged status employment package as a copy editor; his refuge in a British pub in England to narrowly escape a lynching by a mob of skinheads shouting “Paki go home,” and many more such unpredictable or gratifying occurrences.

His brothers had similar unusual experiences. Shiraz, a Makerere University educated doctor wanted to escape his government employment in Tanzania. So he fled to Uganda, only to find himself assigned to Idi Amin’s home town to take care of his prisoners with a possibility of becoming the brutal murderer’s personal physician. He had to flee again, this time to the United States.

The Aga Khan being interviewed by Mansoor Ladha, one of the few Ismaili journalists who has had the privilege to interview the Aga Khan.

1970: Mansoor Ladha interviewing His Highness the Aga Khan for Tanzania’s daily, The Standard (now Daily News). Photo: Mansoor Ladha Collection. Copyright.

Mehboob (Mebs), the youngest brother, was sponsored by Shiraz and his Catholic wife to study in America. The poor chap ended up in a Catholic school where he had to “confess” his sins every week and attend mass. He left with no verdict on his sinfulness but an abiding love of wine.

Ladha himself left his beloved Tanzania as he could no longer live in the post-independence Tanzania where nationalization had rendered his family financially emasculated and Africanization had closed the doors of employment at the highest echelons for all the muhindis. Such elite positions were reserved for Africans, as they were for Europeans in the colonial period.

He did visit his beloved Tanzania twice as a tourist and also made two journeys to his grandparents’ ancestral homes in Gujarat. Canada became his new, permanent home but the barriers facing non-white immigrants surfaced often. Through determination and even daring, he became the editor and publisher of several weeklies in Alberta. Later he retired after selling his newspaper business, making Calgary his home.

Suffice to say, this interesting and enlightening memoir should be worthy of consideration by diasporic book clubs. Most of the fifteen chapters contain experiences, episodes and opinions likely to generate animated exchanges.

Besides being a valuable addition to one’s own library, it would be a suitable gift for your colleagues and neighbors who often ask the diasporic muhindis: “What is your nationality?” But they actually are curious about your country of origin, why you are not black if you came from Africa, and reasons for being in “their” countries.

Finally, many readers may be inspired by Ladha‘s memoir to tell their own stories in their own memoirs.

Date posted: December 27, 2018.

________________________

To acquire Mansoor Ladha’s book including the Kindle Edition please click https://www.amazon.ca/Memoirs-Muhindi-Fleeing-East-Africa/dp/0889774749.

Nizar Motani on the Aga KhanNizar A. Motani has a doctorate from the University of London (SOAS) in African history, specializing in British colonial rule in East Africa. He has been a college professor at Bowdoin College (Brunswick, ME) and Western Michigan University (Kalamazoo, MI). He was the first Publication Officer at the Institute of Ismaili Studies (London, UK). He now lives in Atlanta, Georgia.

Readers will be also be interested in the following pieces by Dr. Motani that were published on Simerg and Barakah: 

___________________

Additional reviews of Mansoor Ladha’s Memoirs at:

Advertisements

One thought on “Book Review of Mansoor Ladha’s Memoirs of a Muhindi: Fleeing East Africa for the West

  1. Nice review by Dr Nizar Motani, himself a refugee from the “brutal” Idi Amin regime in the 1972 Uganda Asians ExpulsionTM.

    Mansoor Ladha takes his departure from the expulsion for his story. He says – according to Dr Motani’s review – that it triggered exoduses from Tanzania and Kenya when in fact those exoduses preceded the Uganda Asian expulsion and were precipitated by Tanzania Asians escaping nationalization in Tanzania and by the Kenya Asians preempting UK closure of their doors to Commonwealth British passport-holders. The UgandaAsians expulsion was sui generis.

    Where Mansoor Ladha’s book must contribute to the East African Asian story (I haven’t read the book, just this review) is in his discussion of why the exodus from Tanzania occurred. From “history generally known” and no doubt elaborated by renowned author Mansoor Ladha it was the nationalizations, the de-Englishization in schools, and the national service. I myself have those from the story of a close Tanga family in my book. The national service is covered in Dr Motani’s review when he says the book has a description of the author going to President Nyerere’s State House as a member of the University of Dar-es-Salaam’s student executive committee to protest the terms of the National Service (which, says Dr Motani , Mr Ladha calls “national servitude”). That visit resulted in an arrest and “deportation” to hometowns. The incident must give us pause: These students at Dar Univ protested Nyerere’s national service policy! Except Ladha all others were Africans. What a lack of patriotism by the educated class! That description does whet our appetite to read the book. Dr Motani adds several, as when he says we get descriptions of the author visiting the palace of the Sultan of Zanzibar for an audience, of the author being the only non-white journalist in two almost-white newspapers in Tanzania and Kenya, and of the author escaping lynching by a mob in England once he got admitted there.

    So, Mansoor Ladha’s book adds to the literature on East African Asian dispersals. My book on the Uganda Asians expulsion adds majorly [sic] To East African Asians it is *the* refugee\disaspora story to tell\read when in the course of just a 90-days deadline almost the whole Uganda Asian community (60,000 or so) was sent apacking out of Uganda.

    The book shatters many myths: To the UK passport-holders the ExpulsionTM was a blessing straight upfront as they had just been waiting their “number” to come up in the British quota process (to get into UK). They were not pennyless. The Canadians in responding to the Asian expulsion were in the first instance responding to UK PM Edward Heath’s plea to “alleviate the humanitarian problem on the overcrowded islands”. The Canadians applied the points-system quite rigorously to the non UK applicants. Thirty thousand or so Asians entered UK and 7,000 Canada.

    I have the above facts in my book from archival sources but I have also stories of how people coped the expulsion in their own words. I have >400 such stories, including the story of the distinguished academician Dr Motani – the very first to write about the expulsion in a compilation by the renowned Africanist academician Prof Michael Twaddle.

    Dr Motani in fact had come to Uganda during the expulsion deadline to visit with his distinguished family. So despite the iconoclasm, raw drama is there aplenty in my book and tears to shed. HH Aga Khan comes through as a “hero” of the expulsion saga for his untiring efforts in resettling Uganda Asians sect-blind in Canada. So does his uncle Prince Sadruddin Aga Khan as head of the UN High Commission for Refugees for coming out the last week of the expulsion deadline to pick up the 6 thousand or so Uganda Asians who had not found refuge in any country. They were taken to HCR centres in five European countries and from there dispersed to scores of countries. HH Aga Khan was bestowed with Uganda’s Head of State Chain for his role at that pivotal moment in Uganda’s history as part of his Diamond Jubilee celebrations on October 9, 2017.

    My book’s done now at 2500 pages and should launch in May.

    I read favourable reviews of Mr Mansoor Ladha’s book all the time and will buy a copy for myself once I am in one of those diaspora countries for us. (I live in Uganda.) I hope he and Dr Motani will review my book!!

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s